Monday, 16 April 2012

"What must be said" The poem that is hurting Israel and embarrassing Germany

A pen is certainly mightier than the sword or a nuclear bomb in this modern times, a poem by Herr Gunther Grass a German Nobelist is making the Israel Zionist real mad and the German caught in an embarrassing situation selling high tech submarines to Israel that can carry and launch nuclear missiles capable of hitting Iran and Europe as well (source here):

What must be said
Why have I kept silent, held back so long,
on something openly practised in
war games, at the end of which those of us
who survive will at best be footnotes?


It's the alleged right to a first strike
that could destroy an Iranian people
subjugated by a loudmouth
and gathered in organized rallies,
because an atom bomb may be being
developed within his arc of power.

Yet why do I hesitate to name
that other land in which
for years – although kept secret –
a growing nuclear power has existed
beyond supervision or verification,
subject to no inspection of any kind?

This general silence on the facts,
before which my own silence has bowed,
seems to me a troubling, enforced lie,
leading to a likely punishment
the moment it's broken:
the verdict "Anti-semitism" falls easily.

But now that my own country,
brought in time after time
for questioning about its own crimes,
profound and beyond compare,
has delivered yet another submarine to Israel,
(in what is purely a business transaction,
though glibly declared an act of reparation)
whose speciality consists in its ability
to direct nuclear warheads toward
an area in which not a single atom bomb
has yet been proved to exist, its feared
existence proof enough, I'll say what must be said.

But why have I kept silent till now?
Because I thought my own origins,
tarnished by a stain that can never be removed,
meant I could not expect Israel, a land
to which I am, and always will be, attached,
to accept this open declaration of the truth.

Why only now, grown old,
and with what ink remains, do I say:
Israel's atomic power endangers
an already fragile world peace?
Because what must be said
may be too late tomorrow;
and because – burdened enough as Germans –
we may be providing material for a crime
that is foreseeable, so that our complicity
will not be expunged by any
of the usual excuses.

And granted: I've broken my silence
because I'm sick of the West's hypocrisy;
and I hope too that many may be freed
from their silence, may demand
that those responsible for the open danger
we face renounce the use of force,
may insist that the governments of
both Iran and Israel allow an international authority
free and open inspection of
the nuclear potential and capability of both.

No other course offers help
to Israelis and Palestinians alike,
to all those living side by side in enmity
in this region occupied by illusions,
and ultimately, to all of us.
Translated by Breon Mitchell. You can read the poem in the original German here.

Now this is a post by Dr. Ismail  on the aftermath of the poem from www.veterans.com:


The Nobelist, the Zionists and Where it Hurts Most

 Ismail Salami

The new poem by German Nobelist Gunter Grass warning the world of a dangerous nuclear Israel left the Israelis with a bitter feeling of rage and revenge in their encounter with truth and the Germans with angst over ties now teetering on the brink of rupture. A first lyrical strike against the Zionist entity, the poem titled What Must Be Said was published on April 4 in the German newspaper Sueddeutsche Zeitung as a reaction to Israel’s repeated threats to launch a strike against Iran in order to prevent the country from acquiring nuclear weapons despite the fact Israel is in possession of over 300 nuclear warheads without the knowledge or acquiescence of the international community. The poem considers Israel as a threat to world peace and warns of the consequences of a military strike against Iran.
Grass’s denigration of Israel as a danger to world peace fell heavy on Germany because the German government seems to be following a secret malicious agenda part of which is focused on the Islamic Republic. Empowering the Israeli regime, which kills Palestinian women and children with impunity, is not only morally wrong but politically incorrect. This is a subtle point Gunter Grass has perceived and expressed with no fear for his life being threatened by the Zionist elements in Germany. To hear such words from the mouth of a German intellectual of an international caliber changes the way the Germans in particular and the rest of Europeans in general see Israel as they are instructed to.
It was quite natural that Israel was not able to suffer the brunt of a German intellectual’s criticism and soon lambasted at the poet and cauterized him as a persona non grata. An Israeli association of Hebrew-language writers called on the Nobel Prize committee and the PEN writers group to slam the German author and his “shameful and immoral positions”.
“They must speak: it is not political, it’s moral, because Grass is complicit in whitewashing the genocidal declarations of Iranian leaders,” the head of the Hebrew Writers’ Association, Herzl Hakak, told AFP.
Where does all this rancor come from?
Their rancor however grew more intense when the Swedish Academy rebuffed the call.
“I wish to point out that Mr Grass received his Nobel Prize in 1999 on literary merit and literary merit alone — this applies to all recipients,” the Academy’s permanent secretary, Peter Englund, said in a statement.
“There is and will be no discussion in the Swedish Academy on rescinding the award.”
Part of the poem criticizes Germany for selling nuke-capable submarines to Israel. In March, Germany announced that it would sell Israel a sixth Dolphin-class submarine capable of carrying nuclear warheads with an operating range of 4,500 kilometers.
Why should Israel need super advanced nuclear submarines? Why should Germany threaten the security in the world by such an uncalculated act?
For a number of reasons only known to itself, Germany has been making ugly efforts in recent years to empower the Israeli regime instead of reining this potentially dangerous power. The sale of the nuke-capable submarines to Israel which is to a large extent subsidized by Germany is part of these sacrificial efforts. Quite obviously, Germany is contributing to the feeling of insecurity Israel is creating in the region and in the world. One can easily envisage a world fraught with horror and death when one contemplates that Israel is already in possession of five sophisticated submarines with the capability to nuke any part of the Middle East and Europe to boot. Isn’t it horrible? Is it not enough to conjure up an image of dereliction and decay? With Israel already having at its disposal over 300 nuclear warheads, Germany is making this nuclear demon even uglier and more horrid by selling its nuke submarines.
Parenthetically, Germany is not alone in empowering the Zionist regime. A new report reveals that Washington has contributed over 115 billion dollars in financial aid to Israel over a period of 64 years, which averages out to about $4.9 million a day. Published by the Congressional Research Service, the report shows that Israel has received more aid from the US than 15 European countries did over the years. It’s amazing to note that over 67 billion dollars of Washington’s aid has been focused on supplying military equipment to Israel. Also, the report reveals that the US has allocated 3.1 billion dollars, around one-fifth of its defense budget, to Israel this year alone.
I don’t have the least intention of speaking in the manner of a cynic or a didactician but these facts and figures deserve due contemplation especially on the part of the American community who are now in financial straits. The US and Germany are of course following their own agendas and Gunter Grass seems to be putting a spoke in Germany’s wheel.
Gunter Grass is a poet and a poet has poetic license. In other words, he has the power to manipulate the language the way he desires. Add to it poetic liberty. i.e. the liberty to give expression to his thoughts. Grass’s cry of protest is indeed a first sign that suggests that anti-Israeli muffled voices in Germany are now becoming loud and clear and that the German government should think well before it proceeds with its perverted and Zionophilic policies.
Grass’s only sin is that in his poem he depicted Israel as the aggressor and Iran as the victim. And this is the part that hurts most.
If a poet does not have the freedom to express his opinion, who has?

Sunday, 15 April 2012

Lynas Gebeng: The fear of radioactivity is exaggerated

I do not know why the Gomen tolerate so much nonsense and scare mongering about the Lynas Rare Earth Processing Plant in Gebeng by the obviously Pakatan inspired and led StopLynas and Himpunan Hijau. 


Its one thing to have the freedom to demonstrate against something that you do not like but this small group of people have crossed the line of decency, its pure scare mongering and what they are doing will not only scare the residents around Gebeng but they will make Malaysia a less attractive place for foreign investors to invest and it will damage Malaysia's precious reputation as a investors' haven in the long run. Malaysia is a global trading nation, we are competing with Vietnam, Indonesia, Thailand and Singapore for FDIs and we certainly do not need local scare mongerers scaring away investors from our country.


About 1% of Malaysia's GDP can be created from the Lynas Gebeng plant when it is fully operational, this is not a small business, it is mega and benefits Malaysia's economy. Mark my words if these demonstrations are not stopped, jobs opportunities will be lost as investors will be scared to invest in a place where the Gomen is flip-flopping in its decision, bending backwards to the demands of selfish minority who is using the Lynas issue as a political battering ram to whack the BN.

The Lynas issue started with PKR YB Fuziah belatedly making noise about Lynas Gebeng, making noise when the plant is being constructed after the relevant Authority approval has been given. 

After much explanation and reports by AELB and the world authority and independent IAEA no less (source here):


Main Findings and Recommendations of IAEA Review Mission - Summary

International safety standards complied with;
The IAEA reported that Lynas has so far met all radiation safety standards imposed on them at the plant by the regulatory authorities (AELB and DOE).These standards meet internationally recognised IAEA safety standards.

Lynas must submit waste management plan for approval
The IAEA said Lynas must submit – before the start of operations – a comprehensive waste management plan for AELB's approval.

The plan should address the following issues:

How waste will be stored or disposed off

What will happen when the project ends and the plant is dismantled

How the environment will be restored to normal use at the end of the project life

AELB should be strengthened
The IAEA said the AELB should be strengthened and given more resources – human, financial, technical – to do its job.


....... after that much explanation by the very patient AELB supported by the IAEA review, the StopLynas gang now goes nuts about the Lynas waste byproduct containing Thorium 232 and draw their inspiration from the ARE plant in Perak which closed down. That the Lynas plant and the ARE plant processed different material to begin with was conveniently not mentioned.

What is Thorium-232?

The early experimental nuclear reactor used thorium as its fuel. Thorium is a safe radioactive material provided you do not inhale or eat it. Thorium will be the future nuclear fuel. The waste will be  black gold in future if we can ensure proper waste storage.Read more here.


How safe is Thorium-232?
The following is a letter from a real expert (sourced here) not the scare mongering pseudo experts:

Fear of Radioactivity in Lynas Rare Earth Plant

Dear Sir,

I just cannot understand what the big fuss is all about with regards to the radioactivity in the Lynas Rare Earth plant.

Thoriun-232 is the only radioactive element associated with rare earth mining and Thorium-232 has been regarded as the future green nuclear fuel.

It is present in the rocks everywhere and even in its purest form radiates only alpha particles.

Alpha particles which consist of 2 protons and 2 neutrons are nothing more than just helium atoms without their electrons.

These alpha particles cannot penetrate more than a few centimeters of air and CANNOT penetrate the human skin.

As such you can hold a lump of pure Thorium-232 in your rubber gloved hands without any danger at all.

Thorium-232 do not produce the dangerous Gamma particles which are ionising high energy, high frequency and extremely short wavelengh electromagnetic waves.

These can easily pass though the whole human body and cause widespread radiation damage.

To be very frank, I do not mind keeping a few thousand kilograms of pure Thorium-232 in my house if someone is kind enough to give me such a valuable substance.

In other words, the fear of radioactivity dangers from the rare earth processing plant is unfounded and grossly exaggerated. What we need to worry is the chemical toxic waste that such plants produce.
But unfortunately all industrial plants produce toxic wastes and the only way to avoid these toxic wastes is for us to remain as a poor agricultural country.

Yours sincerely, 

Dato’ Dr Looi Hoong Wah 
DIMP,AMP, KMN, (MSIA),MRCS (England), LRCP, London) 
MB.,ChB(Manchester), MRCP (UK), FAMM 
Consultant Physician. 
18 Perkampungan BatuSawar, 
Jalan Sungai Lembing, Kuantan, Pahang D.M.


Not enough to convince the skeptics you say? OK....Datuk Dr. Looi also stated that (source here):

Thorium-232 is strongly bound (adsorbed) by soil especially clay soil. The thorium concentration in the clay particles is about 500,000% higher than in the water between the clay particles (the interstitial spaces of the clay particles). So, it cannot be leached out by water or intestinal juice.

When ingested, there is insignificant absorption of the thorium because of this strong bond between clay particles and thorium. Practically all the thorium will be excreted in the faeces with the clay.

So the actual amount of thorium that is absorbed into the blood stream when mixed with clay soil as in the case of the Lynas waste is much, much less than 0.02%.

Since Lynas waste contains 1,650 parts of thorium per million and even if we take the inflated rate of 0.02% absorption, it would mean that to get 0.33g of thorium into the blood stream, we have to swallow 1,000kg (1 tonne) of Lynas waste!

Practically all the data on the carcinogenic effects of thorium-232 was obtained retrospectively from the intravenous use of a massive dose of thorium dioxide called Thorotrast (a 25cc vial of a 25% colloidal suspension of thorium dioxide) in investigative radiological studies.

Studies appear to show that a small number out of the 4 million patients who were given this massive dose of 1 or 2 vials (containing 5.58g to 11.7g of thorium) of Thorotrast, developed cancer especially of the liver 20 to 30 years later in their old age.

So in order to get 5.58g of thorium-232 (equivalent to 1 vial of Thorotrast), we have to swallow an incredible 17,000kg or 17 tonnes of Lynas waste!
I do not think anybody in Kuantan will be able to swallow 17 tonnes of Lynas waste ... and that is assuming that the thorium-232 is not strongly adsorbed to clay particles.

With respect to the inhalation of thorium-232, all studies were conducted on workers in the uranium or thorium mining or refining industry and not on populations in towns like Kuantan, and therefore do not apply to the present issue.

I bet  that it will be physically impossible to even force feed a person 17 tonnes of Lynas waste  for him or her to get cancer. Therefore this scare mongering by the StopLynas or Himpunan Hijau group is certainly not necessary. Lynas Gebeng is safe! You guys want to save the world...get people to quit smoking it will be a more useful endeavour.


Here is a part comment ny Ng Ai Soo taken from here: 

"And what about other polution and/or radiation sources in the environment before Lynas even starts. For example, a 1,000MW coal plant after just 1 year of operation produces 6,000,000 tons of CO2, 44,000 tons of SO2, 22,000 tons of NOx, 320,000 tons of ash containing 400 tons of heavy metals (arsenic, mercury, cadmium, lead etc.) and, here’s the kicker, including 5 tons or Uranium and 12 tons of Thorium from which the radon gas of both decay chains are out the chimney and into our air… and we are building TWO of these now to add to those we already have on the peninsula. Where do we store this waste? Does this waste go into making our roads or construction material? What is Lynas waste in comparison?! How did we manage to put up with that yearly radioactive and toxic waste, and plan to build more of the same, with no objection from you?

Be fair… if you want to protect us from industrial radiation pollution, then tackle the whole lot of them in proportion to their pollution, not just Lynas."
Read his comments in full here.


OK here's a part extract about Lynas Gebeng that can easily be understood by all Malaysians:

Fakta Tentang Lynas Gebeng (Source here)

Maklumat Lynas adalah berdasarkan Fakta Saintifik yang boleh di uji dan di bukti; 


Lynas mengalu-alukan pakar-pakar berkecuali yang berkelayakan bagi menyemak laporan berkaitan dengan keselamatan radiasi dan alam sekitar; 

Lynas mengalu-alukan pakar-pakar berkecuali yang berkelayakan untuk menyertai AELB atau DOE bagi menjalankan ujian mereka sendiri; 

Kilang Lynas TIDAK MERBAHAYA kepada orang awam,pesekitaran dan perkerja; 

Kilang Lynas BUKAN KILANG NUKLEAR..Ia hanya kilang kimia biasa; 

Mengikut undang-undang pengangkutan antarabangsa,bahan Lynas adalah BUKAN bahan radioaktif kerana kandungan radioaktifnya adalah rendah kerana kandungan radioaktifnya adalah rendah; 

Dedahan radiasi kepada orang awam adalah TERAMAT rendah (sila lihat perbandingan di bawah): 



Perlepasan air dan udara dari kilang Lynas TIDAK ada bahan radioaktif; 

Kilang Lynas berteknoloji tinggi dan MEMATUHI undang-undang antarabangsa dan Malaysia; 

Dedahan radiasi oleh kilang Lynas pada orang awam selama setahun hanyalah 0.002mSv. ( Lagi merbahaya radiasi dari menghisap rokok).

Apakah angka dedahan radiasi yang membahayakan manusia? 

Undang-undang Malaysia dan antarabangsa berhubung had dedahan radiasi kepada manusia

1) Orang Awam - tidak melebihi 1.0 mSv setahun

2) Pekerja sinaran - tidak melebihi 20mSv setahun



Lynas TIDAK SAMA dengan Asian Rare Earth (ARE), Bukit Merah :

Bahan mentah kilang ARE di Bukit Merah adalah bahan buangan industri bijih timah,iaitu tahi bijih;

Bahan mentah Lynas adalah tanah dari lombong dan bukan BAHAN BUANGAN;

Kandungan radioaktif bahan mentah Lynas adalah jauh lebih rendah dari bahan mentah dan sisa.  


ARE Bukit Merah

Kandungan radioaktif dalam bahan mentah ARE Bukit Merah adalah 37 kali lebih tinggi dari Lynas; 

Kandungan radioaktif dalam sisa ARE Bukit Merah adalah 60 kali lebih tinggi dari Lynas.

Kenapa Lynas memilih GEBENG?Kenapa tidak Australia?

Lynas telah mendapat kelulusan bina kilang di Australia 

Cadangan pembinaan kilang di Australia Barat di dapati tidak komersial kerana kos yang tinggi dan kekurangan kemudahan asas seperti air,gas asli dan bahan kimia... 

Surat kelulusan pembinaan di Australia di keluarkan oleh pihak kerajaan Australia 

Kenapa Gebeng Pahang?

Lynas telah mendapat kelulusan bina kilang di Gebeng

Kemudahan Pelabuhan yang berdekatan

Bekalan gas asli yang sedia ada

Bekalan bahan Kimia yang sedia ada

Bekalan air yang mencukupi

Wujud tenaga kerja mahir

Kos operasi yang kompetitif secara global


Pengurusan Bahan sisa

Bahan sisa Lynas mengandungi kadar radioaktif yang sanggat rendah dan tidak merbahayakan pada orang awam,alam sekitar dan pekerja; 

Dedahan sinaran dari bahan sisa ke atas orang awam adalah TERAMAT RENDAH (sila rujuk di atas);

Walaupun bahan sisa ini tidak merbahaya,pihak berkuasa mewajibkan ia di simpan di tempat khas sama sepertu industri-industri kimia yang lain;

Lynas melalui makmal antarabangsa telah berjaya menurunkan lagi kadar radioaktif di dalam sisa; 

Negara seperti Amerika Syarikat telah menggunakan kaedah ini untuk membuat jalan. 

Pengurusan Bahan Sisa- Senario Terburuk

Senario terburuk adalah JIKA bahan sisa ini tidak dapat di guna pakai semula Ianya boleh di tangani dengan salah satu daripada cara berikut: 


Bahan sisa ini akan di cairkan (dilute) dengan bahan lain atau tanah biasa untuk menjadikan bahan bukan radioaktif (takrif antarabangsa kurang dari 1 Bq / g adalah bahan bukan radioaktif).Bahan campuran ini boleh di gunakan untuk apa-apa aplikasi yang berfaedah 

atau 

Bahan sisa ini akan di simpan dengan selamat di tempat simpanan sisa kekal yang di rekabentuk mengikut standard antarabangsa setelah mendapat kelulusan AELB dan DOE 

Pelepasan Udara 

Lynas mempunyai Waste Gas Treatment System yang mempunyai 5 peringkat tapisan untuk memastikan pelepasan udara adalah selamat; 

Tahap radioaktif yang di keluarkan adalah amat rendah sehingga sukar di kesan; 

Bahan-bahan yang di proses di Lynas tidak mengandungi Uranium (Tidak Boleh Di Ukur) Ianya mengandungi Thorium yang mempunyai kadar radioaktif yang amat rendah; 

Di sebabkan kadar radio aktif Thorium yang amat rendah,maka gas Thoron (yang mempunyai jangka separuh hayat hanya 55.6 saat) yang di hasilkan juga amat rendah; 

Pendedahan radiasi di pinggir pagar kilang Lynas adalah 0.002mSv setahun (berbanding menonton TV selama 4 jam sehari selama setahun yang memberi radiasi 10 kali lebih tinggi); 

Untuk mengesahkan dan memantau kualiti pelepasan udara.Lynas telah memasang Airborne Monitoring System (AMS) di tapak kilang dan akan memasang satu unit di bandar Kuantan.

Pelepasan Air 

Proses Lynas akan membuatkan Thorium tidak larut dalam air. 

Thorium dan Air ini akan di rawat di Waste Water Treatment Plant 

Air yang telah di rawat tidak mengandungi bahan-bahan radioaktif serta memenuhi 32 parameter yang di tetapkan oleh DOE sebelum di lepaskan ke Sungai Balok 

Kualiti air yang telah di rawat memenuhi piawaian World Health Organization (WHO) 

Selain China, kilang-kilang seperti Lynas yang sedang beroperasi di Negara Maju seperti Amerika Syarikat dan lain-lain 

A Prosesan sepenuh 
Molycorp di California,Amerika Syarikat 
Indian Rare Earth di India 
Solikampsk di Russia & Silmet di Estonia (Eropah) 

B Prosesan separa 
Rhodia di Perancis 

Shin Etsu di Jepun 

Nippon Yttrium di Jepun 

C Kilang-kilang dalam perancangan 
Arafura di Whayalla Australia 
Great Western Minerals di Steenkampskraal South Afrika 
Avalon Rare Metal di Thor Lake Canada 
Alkane di Dubbo New South Wales Australia 

Faedah 

Pelaburan dan kewangan; 

Pelaburan langsung asing (FDI) dengan modal RM2.3 Bilion; 

Fasa pertama - modal pelaburan sebanyak RM1.318 Bilion.RM618 juta di belanjakan di Malaysia termasuk RM235 juta yang di berikan kepada kontrakor di Kuantan; 

Fasa kedua - Modal pelaburan ialah RM700 juta di mana 50% akan di belanjakan di Malaysia; 

Kos operasi ialah RM400 juta setahun / (RM600 juta mulai dari 2013); 

Servis luar -Pengangkutan , penyelengaraan; 
Tenaga kerja - keselamatan , mekanikal , elektrikal , sivil , gudang dan proses. 

Tenaga Kerja 

Lynas akan mengambil 350 pekerja,terdiri dari 75 Ijazah teknikal,15 Ijazah bukan teknikal,dan 260 tenaga mahir dan separa mahir 

250 orang pekerja kontrak yang tetap 

100% Kakitangan Lynas Malaysia termasuk pihak pengurusan adalah rakyat Malaysia kecuali 4 pakar Nadir bumi dari Negara China. 

Industri sokongan akan menjana 1000 peluang pekerjaan tambahan; 

Lynas mendapat sokongan teknikal dari Rhodia,Perancis yang telah mengendalikan logi nadir bumi semenjak tahun 60an. 

Fasa pembinaan 

Lebih 2000 orang di ambil bekerja pada kemuncak fasa pembinaan. 

Menyediakan peluang perniagaan untuk kontraktor dan pembekal tempatan 

Aktiviti Perintis 

Besar kemungkinan,syarikat-syarikat yang menggunakan produk Lynas akan mendirikan kilang di Malaysia seperti - Magnet Rare Earth - Siemens telah menanda tangani kerjasama dengan Lynas untuk mendirikan kilang magnet dengan anggaran pelaburan - RM500 juta 

Produk Teknologi Hijau

- Hybrid vehicle 

- Catalytic converters 

- Polishing powder 

- Flat Panel Display 

- Ceramic capacitors 

- Compact fluorescent light 

- Fuel cells  

- NiMH batteries


I say to the StopLynas and Himpunan Hijau folks, be objective be fair, if you guys are really concerned about the environment then show some sincerity don't just go for Lynas Gebeng go after all those industries that could cause radiation and produce toxic waste, of course it will make millions of Malaysians jobless and Malaysia lose a lot of money and we should all balik kampung tanam jagung or padi, you minorities sure would like that shoved down the throat of the majority wouldn't you. 

God bless this country whose majority understands the risk and benefits of industrialisation even though the Gomen is painfully tolerating the antics of this so called selective environmentalists in StopLynas and Himpunan Hijau.

Instead of selfishly go on a campaign to stop Lynas Gebeng, the responsible way would be to ensure that the rare earth processing plant is monitored during its operation and waste treatment and storage process. This the AELB will do, and they have much expertise to do what needs to be done. I trust that the AELB will do their job well.

Tuesday, 10 April 2012

PTPTN for Dummies and why Anwar Ibrahim will never be Prime Minister


The Perbadanan Tabung Pendidikan Tinggi Nasional or PTPTN for short which had helped many Malaysian to achieve their ambition (1,926,054 students to be exact) is under siege. Some time ago our permanent wannabe PM in waiting announced that he would abolish PTPN if he comes in power. Its a rather daft and desperate suggestion, and the chances of Anwar actually fulfilling his promises is as remote as Lim Kit Siang becoming Prime Minister, but nevertheless this PTPTN issue needs to be explained to the graduates and their parents who took up the PTPN loan, so they will understand the relevance of this very important national education aid scheme.

Dr Khir wrote in his blog, sourced here, about the PTPTN which I think is a great fact based and rational discussion which I shall call a PTPTN guide for DUMMIES:

Hipokrasi Anwar dan Wajah PTPTN Yang Perlu Diubah


1. Baru-baru ini saya berjumpa dengan sekumpulan mahasiswa yang begitu terpengaruh dengan janji Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim untuk menghapuskan pinjaman Tabung Pendidikan Tinggi Nasional (PTPTN). Mereka yang terpengaruh dengan janji Pakatan ini tidak memahami sejarah dan pemimpin yang mewujudkan PTPTN sendiri. 

2. Apabila Anwar mengumumkan beliau akan menghapuskan pinjaman PTPTN mereka bersorak sakan tanpa melihat asal ususl kemunculan dana ini. 

3. Pada awal 1991, Perdana Menteri Keempat, Datuk Seri Dr. Mahathir Mohamad (Tun) mengumumkan pelan jangka panjang Wawasan 2020 iaitu ke arah menjadikan Malaysia sebuah negara maju yang berasaskan kepakaran dan teknologi serta mewujudkan rakyat berpendapatn tinggi. Justeru, mahu tidak mahu jumlah pelajar pengajian tinggi juga perlu ditambah dengan banyaknya agar selari dengan hasrat Wawasan 2020 itu.

4. Selain itu, perkembangan pesat Institut Pengajian Awam dan Swasta, kemunculan begitu ramai pelajar yang lulus cemerlang dalam pengajian peringkat menengah sejak penghujung alaf lalu menyaksikan kerajaan tidak lagi mampu menyediakan peruntukan yang besar dalam pemberian pinjaman dan biasiswa melalui Jabatan Perkhidmatan Awam seperti sebelum itu.

5. Atas sebab itulah kerajaan menubuhkan Perbadanan Tabung Pendidikan Tinggi Nasional (PTPTN) melalui Akta Perbadanan Tabung Pendidikan Tinggi Nasional 1997 (Akta 566). 

Hipokrasi Anwar Ibrahim

6. Siapakah Timbalan Perdana Menteri dan Menteri Kewangan ketika PTPTN ini ditubuhkan? Nyata sekali PTPTN ditubuhkan di bawah batang tubuh pemimpin yang hari ini ke hulu ke hilir mendakwa PTPTN menekan mahasiswa, zalim dan merupakan tanggungjawab kerajaan untuk memberi pendidikan percuma sehingga ke universiti.

7. Tujuan PTPTN ialah untuk mengambil alih peranan Jabatan Perkhidmatan Awam (JPA) yang sebelum ini merupakan agensi pemberian pinjaman pendidikan terbesar kerajaan selain Majlis Amanah Rakyat (MARA). PTPTN bertujuan mewujudkan satu tabung pinjaman pendidikan yang tidak lagi memerlukan peruntukan kerajaan saban tahun seperti JPA sebelum ini.

8. Malangnya PTPTN bermula dengan langkah yang salah apabila mengenakan caj sehingga 4% setahun ke atas pinjamannya. Ini menimbulkan kemarahan para pelajar yang terasa mereka dibebani oleh pinjaman pendidikan yang terlalu tinggi apabila mula bekerja.

9. Tapi sekali lagi pengenaan caj 4% ini dilakukan di bawah pengawasan Menteri Kewangan mana? Orang yang sama hari ini yang mendakwa pinjaman PTPTN dan caj pengurusan, yang jauh lebih rendah daripada zaman beliau, sebagai zalim dan menindas mahasiswa.

10. Namun kerajaan Barisan Nasional yang prihatin ini kemudiannya menurunkan kepada 3%dan setereusnya menganjurkan skim baru yang hanya mengenakan caj perkhidmatan sebanyak 1% sahaja. Dan ingatlah semua ini berlaku bukan lagi pada zaman pemimpin "rakyat" bernama Anwar Ibrahim memegang kuasa.

11. Sungguhpun kita mengetahui sikap hipokrasi pemimpin Pakatan ini, namun kita juga harus menerima hakikat bahawa wajah, struktur dan bentuk PTPTN boleh diberi nafas baru yang menjadikannya lebih mesra rakyat.

PTPTN Perlukan Perubahan Drastik

12. Sehingga tahun lalu seramai 885,564 peminjam Perbadanan Tabung Pendidikan Tinggi Nasional (PTPTN) perlu membayar balik pembiayaan pendidikan masing-masing yang berjumlah RM5.3 bilion. Pada Oktober tahun lalu, Timbalan Menteri Pengajian Tinggi, Dr. Hou Kok Chung berkata, 114,125 peminjam telah diluluskan penangguhan bayaran balik disebabkan menyambung pelajaran, masih belum bekerja dan dalam proses tawaran yang melibatkan amaun sebanyak RM967.18 juta.

13. Ini bermakna masih ada lagi ruang untuk pelajar yang telah lulus pengajian memohon penangguhan bayaran semula. Namun masih ramai yang tidak berpuas hati kerana PTPTN mewajibkan mereka mula membayar balik enam bulan selepas habis pengajian. Jika tidak mampu membayar maka perlu melakukan rayuan dan bergantung atas budi bicara para pegawai PTPTN. Malahan saya dimaklumkan PTPTN mempunyai budi bicara untuk mengurangkan bayaran bulanan sehingga serendah RM 50 sebulan.

14. Namun masalah yang besar ialah mengenai jumlah yuran pengajian yang begitu tinggi di Institut Pengajian Tinggi Swasta sehingga menyebabkan ada antara pelajar lulusan vokasional dan teknik berhutang dengan PTPTN sehingan RM 45 ribu ke 50 ribu sebaik tamat pengajian.

15. Dalam keadaan inilah kerajaan harus menganggap memberi pinjaman pendidikan tinggi kepada para pelajar merupakan satu bentuk pelaburan yang kalau tidak lebih penting pun tentulah sama penting dengan pelaburan pembangunan lain.

16. Pada hemat saya PTPTN perlu menggunakan skim pembayaran balik pinjaman MARA yang lebih mesra pelajar dan sangat bertimbang rasa. Ini membolehkan pelajar menikmati pelbagai potongan diskaun selain menggalakkan kerja keras mahsiswa menumpukan kepada pelajaran. Jika pelajar yang mendapat kelulusan baik diberi potongan tertentu, maka lebih ramai yanga akn menumpukan kepada pelajaran berbanding menghabiskan masa berhibur dan berdemontrasi.

17. PTPTN sebagai organisasi yang berkait rapat dengan kerajaan tidak harus menjadi seperti bank yang mengenakan pelbagai caj dan faedah sehingga membebankan mahasiswa.

18. PTPTN mendapat dana permulaan daripada kerajaan. Saya percaya kerajaan boleh menambah dana tersebut jika PTPTN mempunyai strategi yang berkesan untuk menjadi sebuah organisasi yang mapan pada masa akan datang. 

19. Justeru PTPTN harus mengambil langkah seperti MARA yang kini khabarnya mempunyai cabang pelaburan sendiri bagi mengumpul dana untuk organisasi dan aktiviti mereka. Atau sekurang-kurangnya PTPTN boleh mencontohi model pengurusan dan pelaburan Kumpulan Wang Simpanan Pekerja (KWSP)yang mampu mendapat keuntungan bagi menampung kos operasi dan membayar dividen kepada penyimpannya. 

20. PTPTN boleh memohon dana khas kerajaan untuk pelaburan dalam industri tertentu yang tidak berisiko tinggi tetapi mempunyai pulangan sederhana. Kos pengurusan PTPTN dan juga kerugian daripada pemberian diskaun kepada pinjaman pelajar boleh ditampung dari sumber keuntungan pelaburannya, bukan daripada pinjaman pendidikan itu sendiri seperti yang berlaku sekarang. 

21. Dengan peruntukan berbilion daripada kerajaan, adalah mustahil untuk PTPTN tidak mampu untuk mencari peluang pelaburan yang mencukupi untuk membiayai pengurusan organisasinya dan juga menampung kekurangan dana pinjaman akibat pelupusan dan juga pengurangan bayaran balik pinjaman. 

22. PTPTN juga boleh melakukan pelbagai aktiviti mengutip dana untuk tabung pinjaman ini jika syarikat korporat, dermawan dan rakyat percaya mereka membuat kerja membantu mahasiswa bukannya menindas mahasiswa.

23. Yang utuma dan penting ialah PTPTN tidak seharusnya mengambil jalan senang dengan memberi pinjaman dan mengutip bayaran semata-mata sehingga ia menjadi satu bebanan politik kepada rakyat. 

24. Belajarlah daripada agensi lain terutamanya daripada MARA yang bukan sahaja berupaya menaja para pelajar ke luar negara tetapi juga memberi pinjaman yang sangat fleksibel dan mesra mahasiswa.

As a MARA Scholar myself, I wholeheartedly agree with Dr. Khir.......there are some weaknesses to the PTPTN system which should be addressed to make it more friendly and less of a burden to graduates. 

Here is a summary info of the condition for release from PTPTN commitments from Kosmo  (sourced here):



Footnote: My son has no problem with PTPTN payments as he has never taken  a loan to study, his is on a Ma & Pa scholarship. I and my wife, we do our part to ensure that others less fortunate will have a chance to get loan for their studies.

Sunday, 8 April 2012

Standing By "Najib Razak and the BN" is certainly Fine By Me

I just love this You Tube montage highlighted by Rocky Bru here. 

After three years as our PM, YAB Najib Razak has certainly shown why we should stand by him and the moderate BN, against a Pakatan Rakyat whose leaders are very long on promises but certainly short in keeping them, and will shortly enter the Guinness Book of World Records as the largest political coalition whose leaders are NOT elected (Anwar Ibrahim,Lim Kit Siang/Lim Guan Eng, Nik Aziz). 

 Enjoy:


Yup, Stand by Najib Razak and the BN is certainly Fine by Me

read also:

Friday, 6 April 2012

An awesome argument for a Satu Sekolah Untuk Semua system in Malaysia


"Can we seriously expect there to be some semblance of a Malaysian nation as long as young Malaysian children are taught separately, in different language streams? And are we naïve enough to think that nations invent themselves, without there having to be some form of intervention and direction by the state?"
Dr. Farish A. Noor


This is one of the best article I have read arguing for a one school for all system, written by Dr. Farish A. Noor, sourced here:

A common language to success
By Farish A. Noor

ONCE again vernacular education has become an issue in Malaysian politics, though with much speculation about the date of the election going around at the moment, one cannot help but feel that the issue has been raised by some parties for the sake of gaining the popular vote above all.

It would be difficult not to draw an association between the proponents of vernacular schooling and the opposition parties after what happened at the rally for Chinese schools that took place last week.
But the question remains unanswered by all: Can we seriously expect there to be some semblance of a Malaysian nation as long as young Malaysian children are taught separately, in different language streams? And are we naïve enough to think that nations invent themselves, without there having to be some form of intervention and direction by the state?

I have written about this so many times that I am close to giving up altogether, for fear that any more articles would simply amount to a waste of paper.

But for the umpteenth time, let me repeat some of the things I have said before: If we were to look at the major developed countries of the world such as Britain, France and Germany, we will see that historically these countries used to be far more linguistically diverse than they are today. In France alone hundreds of dialects were spoken, as was the case in Germany, where each region had a dialect unique to itself.

As Robert Bartlett has argued in his work The Making Of Europe, the coming together of these small principalities and feudal states was only possible through the centralisation of power and the streamlining of language, giving birth to the national languages we know today: French, German and English. Bartlett notes, of course, that this did not happen without some degree of discomfort, but in the long run the sacrifices of the past seem to have paid off. Disparate communities (that may not have even been able to speak to each other) are now part of larger nations.

Malaysia is likewise at a stage of its history where it has to decide firmly and decisively if it wishes to be one nation or a number of nations living side-by-side but never really communicating or understanding one another. As elections draw close, my worry is that the political parties of the country will pander to the most exclusive of communitarian voices, calling for linguistic isolationism as if it was the only benchmark of identity.

Surely, in the midst of the economically troubling times we live in, there are other matters that ought to gain our attention, such as protecting Malaysia from capital flight, securing our human resources and talent, and so on.

This also means having to create the opportunity structures whereby minorities feel that they can succeed by remaining in the mainstream, and working upwards in society by using the same common national language that is the language of one and all. For more than two decades now, I have lived as a member of the minority, first in Britain, then in France, Holland, Germany and now in Singapore.
In all these countries, I found myself struggling to get into the mainstream in order to succeed and to be the best I could be; proud enough to say that at least one Malaysian managed to teach in some of the best universities of the world. In places like France and Germany it also meant trying to master at least some basic French and German. And in all these instances my struggle was for and in the mainstream of society.

My concern about what is happening in Malaysia today is that the continued existence of separate language schools means that we do not know where the mainstream is any longer. It beggars belief that in a plural society like ours, young children may spend their entire childhood in the company of other children of the same cultural-linguistic background, and need not meet or even shake hands with another Malaysian child of a different culture or religion.
Worse still, this trend towards linguistic-cultural exclusivism seems to be on the rise among all the communities of the country. So we are back to the original question: How can we build a Malaysian nation if Malaysian children don't even go to the same schools, together?

As the tone and tenor of political contestation heats up in Malaysia in the lead-up to the elections, I also hope that the parties in the country will not jump on the language bandwagon to further aggravate things and to drive a wedge between Malaysians. In other developed countries, even parties that are bitterly hostile to each other conduct themselves with one eye on the national interest, and put national interest first.

In any plural society there are bound to be both centrifugal forces and centripetal forces, at times working against each other. To build a Malaysian nation means necessarily seeking those positive centripetal forces that want there to be a Malaysian nation that we can all call home. Parties should actively seek these forces, and lend their support to Malaysians who want there to be a national language, a national educational system and a national culture that everyone can identify with.

These forces, I believe, are there and have always been there; but what baffles me is why the political parties of the country have not reached out to them in an effective manner.

The aim, surely, has to be the creation of a common, inclusive mainstream; and then the expansion of that mainstream to make it even more inclusive and empowering for all.

Surely that is what education is for, and what smart politics is all about. Read in full here.

I seriously think that politicians from both sides of the political divide should sit down together and decide on a One School For All System for the sake of this nations future. Our children and our grandchildren who are taught  segregated  in their own schools will never grow up as a united people.

Jurang perpaduan kaum diMalaysia semakin besar dan semakin runcing dengan adanya pelbagai sekolah untuk mengisi kemahuan pelbagai kaum diMalaysia ini. Its time rational Malaysians take the future of this country in their hands and tell our politicians to buck up and look at the future not just the votes they will get.

Its time for  "Satu Sekolah Untuk Semua"

SSS_Final1 v2